A solid homogeneous cylinder has diameter D and length L. It floats upright (axis vertical) in fresh water. The cylinder's specific gravity is 0.65. For what ratio L/D does the cylinder become unstable in the upright position? Determine whether a cylinder with L = 1.0 m and D = 0.80 m and SG = 0.65 is stable.
Draft: $d = SG \cdot L = 0.65L$. KB = d/2 = 0.325L. BM for circular section rotating about diameter:
$$I = \frac{\pi D^4}{64}, \quad V_d = \frac{\pi D^2}{4}(0.65L)$$
$$BM = \frac{I}{V_d} = \frac{\pi D^4/64}{\pi D^2(0.65L)/4} = \frac{D^2}{16(0.65L)} = \frac{D^2}{10.4L}$$
$$BG = KG - KB = \frac{L}{2} - 0.325L = 0.175L$$
$$GM = BM - BG = \frac{D^2}{10.4L} - 0.175L$$
For neutral stability: $GM = 0 \Rightarrow D^2 = 1.82L^2 \Rightarrow L/D < 1/\sqrt{1.82} = 0.741$ for stability.
Check for L = 1.0 m, D = 0.80 m (L/D = 1.25):
$$BM = \frac{(0.80)^2}{10.4(1.0)} = 0.0615 \text{ m}, \quad BG = 0.175(1.0) = 0.175 \text{ m}$$
$$GM = 0.0615 - 0.175 = -0.114 \text{ m (unstable)}$$
Answer: A floating cylinder is stable upright only when $L/D < 0.741$. For the given cylinder (L/D = 1.25), GM = −0.114 m — it will tip over to float on its side.